Perspectives - August 20, 2000 - Andrew Kaufmann
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed within this column are those of
the participants and the moderator, and do not necessarily reflect those of the GIA. There
is coarse language and potentially offensive material afoot. Peer pressure. Don't say we didn't warn you.
Tomorrow will be Drew's farewell column for his little guest stint. Start preparing your questions.
Not so final sketches |
Yo AK,
I was looking through the stuff about FFIX on your site, starting back with
your total scoop of the story a year and a half before the game was released
in Japan. Looking at the pics, it's obvious that it's FFIX, with the CG
airship render and Vivi in them. However, there were other pictures, the
blond haired boy with the sword (definately not Zidane) and the dark skinned
girl. Do you or Vestal, or anyone there that's played the game know what
happened to these characters and the other stuff? Were they in the game or
just very early renditions of other characters?
--The Steve
|
I went to Mr. Andrew Vestal for the reply, and here it is: some characters, like the Dark Knight, were
worked into the story as the supporting character of Blank (that's a character's name). Some characters,
like Freya and Quina, were recognizable in their early forms. But, for the most part, they were intended
as conception sketches, not production sketches, that were intended to set a tone: a return to high
fantasy.
Travesty for Rhapsody |
I was reading one of the stories on the GIA website, and I found a little
tidbit that has been gnawing away at me ever since. The line was in the
story about the game that would be Rhapsody 3. It reads:
"Unfortunately, after the sales debacle Atlus experienced in localizing the
first game, don't hold your breath to see the third in the series hit
American shoes."
Sales debacle? Rhapsody didn't sell well? What gives? People keep whining
about games like Legend of Dragoon not having innovation, but when a game
comes out that actually ATTEMPTS to add something, even if it's just a
gimmick, to the genre, this is the response it gets. Thousand Arms,
Rhapsody, any Artdink title... these games can only aspire to become sleeper
hits, IF they're lucky. But games like Spec Ops (the cheap-o title), Frogger
(the Hasbro game), and anything Squaresoft sell like crack.
Kyo's letter yesterday about conformity finally prompted me to get vocal.
People claim they want new stuff, they complain about unoriginal concepts,
and they gripe about how the new stuff lacks that "something". It seems
that's just lip service. If folks really wanted new and improved, they'd
spend their money that way. It seems that for conformity's sake, old and
inferior will do nicely.
-Some Random Jerk
|
Well, a game's popularity depends on a number of things. For it to be a big
hit, it needs to have something that appeals to large number of people, like
pretty graphics (FF7/8), or killing your friends (Goldeneye), or having
cute characters (Pokemon). Otherwise, you're generally going to hit a niche.
And success within the niche is dependent on more than just innovation. Innovation
is great, but it's not everything. Rhapsody had a great concept, but from reviews
I gather it didn't deliver enough to be a hit.
Mangled memory |
Ok so far I love the game, hands down it is a phenominal title. The
thing that is bugging me horribly as that occasionally my save games
will go bad, and not becase of a memory card either. I'll start up my
game and i'll load up a save either from mem card one or two (both are
known to e reiliable) and it'll tell me that my save is unusable. This
is really frustrating because I lost four hours of game play time and
it's the second time this has happened, i'm incredibly frustrated do you
have any idea what's going on?
--
Jon
|
Not mentioned in the letter is that he's referring to Chrono Cross. Are you sure
your memory cards aren't bad? This is the first Vestal or I have heard of this
happening. If you're sure it's not your cards, then I'd try contacting Square.
Accents? No biggie |
"Could Square's "Fresh and Masterful" translation be turning off more people
than attracting them to the game?"
Today's letter from Duncan Burris caught my eye, because I've been pondering
about the accents quite a bit. I mean, they're all so very colourful, and
apparently done by an accent generator for the most part (look in the back of
the booklet. Some guy did the localization fluff and it also has 'English
accent generator' before his name as well)... personally, I love the accents,
from Harle's French stereotype to Doc's surfer dude thing.
And 'Oi!' is very fun to say out loud. *blinks*
But I digress, anyways, I think that overall, the game is just too good to
worry about accents. I think I've lost sleep over it.
I wonder about the Japanese version, were there accents there? *tilt*
~nezu, and it's misspell.
|
Overall, I agree with you. I get a little irked at the accents sometimes,
but not enough to dislike the game.
The story behind the accents is that there were accents in the Japanese versions,
but they were different Japanese accents and dialects. There's no relationship
between the Japanese and English accents. When they say "English accent generator"
they probably mean someone that turned normal speech into slang.
Chrono Cross again |
AK,
I'm an African American male who when reading Duncan's letter about
Chrono Cross, was reminded of the controversy over Barret's slang in FF7.
Next Generation claimed that they had considered giving the game one star to
penalize it for its 'horrible offense'. I'm an African American male who
wonders then and wonders now what the excitement is about. Barrett and Kid
are both great characters who have streaks of nobility that more than offset
their use of slang. Of course, accents are rarely, if ever going to be
perfect reflections of the real thing (partly because the 'real' thing is
everchanging). And of course, accents might be overdone in order to enhance
the comic or dramatic potential of a situation. So what? Unless one wants
Square to restrict itself to worlds where all of the characters are
Caucasians who speak flawless English, I suggest that people learn not to
view less than accurate (or even less than flattering) portayals as
malicious attacks. I personally am hoping that there will come a time when
rpgs feature black villians as well as black heros (yes, there was Raijin in
FF8 but he was more of a loyal friend of evil than a man dedicated to it),
because I think villians are often some of the coolest characters.
- Mark
P.S. - To all the non-Chrono Cross owners reading this letter - BUY IT! Its
more beautiful than Final Fantasy 8, has a translation as good as Vagrant
Story's, a battle system more dynamic that Grandia's, music superior to that
of the original Suikoden, a more complex story than Xenogears, and wilder
and more inventive characters than anything out there.
|
Point well taken. Glad to have heard your perspective, it illuminates the
other side. Thanks Mark!
More Chrono Cross frustration |
Dear Double Agen dude,
Okay, lemme just say that I'm 14, and every time I walk into Babbages
without my dad the people there get really rude. But nonetheless I bought a
copy of Chrono Cross there. It keeps freezing my PS, and if I can accually
make it past the intro without anything screwing up and start a new game...
the stipid game starts to malfunction again. I don't want to return the damn
thing, because the dudes at babbages always get snooty. Is there a chance
that the problem could be my PS or is it CC??
~Heather, who really wants to play Chrono Cross....
|
Oops. That was probably me being rude. Sorry about that, Heather.
Anyway, FMV-heavy games often cause problems for PlayStations. Mine has
issues with them unless I turn my PSX upside-down. It's kinda a bad
solution, I hear it doesn't really help the system any, but it does work
sometimes as a stopgap solution. Give it a try, see if it improves. You
also might want to try taking your PSX somewhere to have it recalibrated.
I'm not sure what places do this, but you might also ask your friends if they
know how, as it's not that difficult. Good luck!
A man from another land |
Hey there AK,
I have always heard bout chrono cross, the older final fantasy games for the nes/snes etc, but to be honest i have NEVER played any of them, mainly cause in this backward little country of mine nobody ever eard of video games in those days unless you loadsa cash to import the bloody stuff.
Well FINALLY, about a week or so ago i had the opportunity to play Final Fantasy 3 ( the one where four kids fall down a hole, beat a monster and some crystal gives them super powers etc etc ), i'm not sure if it is 3 or whatever one it is, correct me plz. For some reason this game really pulled me in and litterally i couldn't put it down, i've scoped all the towns now, but there is this damn rock blocking the way to the southern part of the continent, help?.
Another gr8er surprise was that on saturday, i obtained my own copy of Chrono Cross, now that is one hell of a game!! i luv everythingb out it, the battle system, graphics, characters, music EVERYTHING. i know now i really missed out on a lot in those days but at least i have the joy of playing them now. I just saved princess nadia and i'm now escaping from the prison part. wish me luck, i luv these 2 games *g* :))))
cya, wouldn't wanna be ya
|SaVaGe|
|
Haha! A great story. This message came from the .za domain, which is South Africa, I believe.
Thanks!
Closing Comments:
Tomorrow, Drew does a goodbye column of sorts. Mail him messages saying you love him. It'll
make him feel good. Take care!
-Andrew Kaufmann
|
| |
| |