Is there such a thing as perfection? -
July 8, 2000 -
Andrew Kaufmann
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed within this
column are those of
the participants and the moderator, and do not necessarily reflect
those of the GIA. There
is coarse language and potentially offensive material afoot. Despite
all my rage, I am still just a
little jellybean. Don't say we didn't warn you.
Word from across the ocean is that Final Fantasy IX is out, and most of
Japan has ceased all productivity
in favor of playing games. Oh, how I eagerly await the day that it is
released here in the U.S. I might
just go bonkers waiting.
Oh yeah, since Chris put up a letters FAQ, I thought I'd follow suit...
some other time. I was far too
lazy to do so tonight. But it'll be pretty short and simple, so don't
worry too much about it. The main
thing in it will be stuff about myself, not that anyone really frequently
asks stuff about me. I like
to pretend, though.
Double your fun with
Dolby |
Just an addendum to the Dolby Digital / Dolby Surround stuff floating
around
the Double Agent column, AK - it seems Square at some point or another has
the Dolby Digital 5.1 standard in mind - its a great thing for DVD.
Anybody who managed to spend some time at Creative Lab's E3 booth would
have
surely discovered CL's new Playstation 2 ready speaker system, and better
yet, the DVD containing all of the CG sequences from Final Fantasy 8.
They
had a Digital 5.1 decoder there, which probably helped the sound output a
little, but nonetheless, it was very cool to sit back on a leather couch
and
watch/listen to that beautiful CG. The sound logo's popped up every-time
the DVD went on repeat play.
The sad thing, of course, is that you do so much standing/walking at the
show, that the couch is far more important than anything else!
Richard "KZ" Knight
|
Good info from the ole KZ, as always. Thanks for the goods!
A
correction |
Hey AK
Drew was the one who said this, but I'm gonna harass you about it ok? I
don't think all games will seem outdated one day, just the most gimmicy
and
experimental ones. I still love Ninja Gaiden, River City Ransom is still
the
best street brawler game out there (in my opinion), and most people still
enjoy Pac Man quite a bit. I think that when a game does something really
new, that's just barely in reach of the hardware, it will eventually seem
dated. Like Metal Gear Solid wukk still be fun when MGS2 comes out, but
the
way that the bodies flash and disappear, and the fact that you don't have
the
opportunity avoid a simple ambush (after the sniper wolf fight) will be
laughable (ha!).
And since I mentioned Ninja Gaiden, why do the henchmen just wander back
and forth, hunched over in pain, hoping to hit you? See that's a typical
old
school thing, but doesn't quite affect the gameplay significantly.
Gilbert
|
I think games will have an outdated feel, but not necessarily be lesser
games.
For instance, when I play Zelda, I think to myself, "Wow, this is
primitive!" But I also
think to myself, "Dang, this is good stuff!" Concepts don't become
outdated, but presentation
does.
Also, you list spectacular games for the NES. Average ones have been
forgotten... and likely,
average PSX games will be forgotten. You don't often hear people
marvelling over Beyond the
Beyond, do you? (Not that they ever did.)
Hair care
tips |
Sorry, but Chris was wrong regarding his theory on why abnormal hair
colours
ended with the start of the PSX era of Final Fantasy. He even recalls
that
Amano portrayed characters like Terra with blonde hair, yet never
considers
why the programmers would make them differently in-game. Yet, it should
also be noted that the menu screen is also different from the character
graphics. The simple reason was to make it easier for players to
distinguish the small pixelicious graphics apart from each other. Unless
you have a good imagination, those tiny sprites can be difficult to make
out
at all; 3 similiar looking ones all with same hair colour makes it that
much
more annoying. With the onset of 3D graphics, characters could be
distinguished by obvious differences in body shape, their clothing, skin
colour and whatnot, so there was no need to alter their hair colour. That
being said, Amano's art and the menu portraits are the true depictions.
Yes, Rydia DOES have green hair. Until there is another party member in
the
series that returns from time compressed monster ruled world, they will
probably continue to have natural hair colours.
- ^Deusfaux^
|
Hmm. I had never given this aspect much consideration. I think
it's a pretty sensible
explanation. But since I'm not pixel based, does this mean I have
no excuse to bleach my
hair?
Legend of dragging
on |
AK,
What do you think of Legend of Dragoon getting a
perfect score from Dailyradar and a 4/5 from NextGen?
Are people stupid, or just blind? Cause you'd have to
be either of those things to give Legend of Dragoon
more than it deserves: a big, fat zero. (this only
based on the wretched dialogue)
Bravo to the GIA for doing what's right.
---Anthony James Larrea
|
I finally got a chance to play a little of Legend of Dragoon, and I was
thoroughly unimpressed.
Those reviews almost seem like they were written by someone who had never
played an RPG before.
It's rather befuddling. If Legend of Dragoon gets a perfect score, what
does FF8 merit? And FF9?
A 49 out 5?
Count your lucky
stars |
Frankly, I think people need to worry less about what's wrong with
gaming and just game. The world is a horrible place where the most evil
and corrupt people always win, anyone can be put down with a bullet from
a gun easily obtainable illegally on any street corner, the law is
corrupt, the people are hateful and stupid, half the population of the
planet lives in squalor, and nobody cares. We the gaming community are
among the absolute luckiest people on Earth. We have wealth beyond the
wildest imagination of most, and the innate horror and corruption of
humanity is somewhat hidden from us living in the upper tiers of society
as we do. Is it really...REALLY...that hard to just enjoy something for
a change, instead of nitpicking? We're fragile beings, and life is
inherently bad. The time we have now is fleeting, and soon we will all
have turned into the dust beneath the feet of the uncaring world. In the
end, the happiness we have now may be the only glimmer of worth in our
miserable lives. So why, WHY, do people have to turn EVERYTHING into an
opportunity to complain and bitch? JUST ENJOY YOUR FREAKING VIDEO GAMES
AND BE HAPPY YOU HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY, PEOPLE! Eesh.
-AJ
|
A little perspective from AJ. I think I agree with you, man. To some
extent,
discussion is great, because it helps you decide which games you like, and
maybe
a budding game designer in the audience will revolutionize the gaming
world because
of something he saw in this very letters column.
But back in reality, gamers are lucky to have the money to afford games.
Heck, I've
gotten paid actual U.S. currency for sitting around and writing about
video games.
It's almost unfair, when you think about it.
I picture a 5 year old
trying to figure out Vagrant Story's weapon system |
AK,
I did a Good Thing today. I was in Software Etc. today, and a man and his
young son were looking for a new PlayStation game. The man turned to me
and
said (no kidding) "You look like an expert on video games. What's new,
what
would you recommend?"
So I handed him Vagrant Story.
Jon
|
I was going to give you serious props, but then I stopped to think for a
minute.
Was this man shopping for himself or his kiddie? ANd how old was the
kiddie? If he
was a real youngster, I'm not sure that Vagrant Story was quite the ideal
game to
recommend. I can imagine young players being confounded by the complexity
(heck, I
was often confounded, and I'm 21 years old). Not only that, it's pretty
violent.
I think if the kid is 12-14 or so, he'd be cool with it, but younger than
that and
you might have scared someone and his father away from the Playstation.
But, I like the way you think! I don't mean to burst your bubble or
anything, just
making sure we think things out, right? Right.
In a related yet totally unrelated story, I was at Blockbuster with my
roommate today.
While we were browsing DVDs, a man came up to us asking to recommend
something with
crazy cool sound that he could check out the awesomeness of his new stereo
with. We
pointed out Twister. He walked away. I guess he doesn't like bad
weather.
Original is
overrated? |
AK,
If Rayeth decides not to play another story-oriented game until a truly
original story comes out, he'll be deprived of games for the rest of his
life. Hell, he could do the same thing for movies and he'll be better off
locked in his basement. Pretty much most stories are "unoriginal". Just
look at American Beauty. If you really think about it, it's just a bunch
of horny people looking for sex. It's how the story is done that makes it
enjoyable. And yes, I loved American Beauty, so you don't have to convince
me that it's good.
The problem with many game stories (especially recent RPGs) is that they
try to make them this totaly original story by filling it with "plot
twists" and a lot of contrived crap not unlike the whole X-Files mythology
arc. "Characterization" is limited to some quest in the middle of the game
where the character solves some problem with his family or finds out
something about his past or something. Unfortunately, when an RPG finally
does away with this and has actual characterization (Final Fantasy 8),
it's largely not liked by the RPG community. Oh well, what do I know, I
watch X-Files for the stories and characters, not the mythology and all
that other crap about viral apocalypses. Thank God he finally found his
damn sister, I'm sick of all the fake ones..
As for your concerns towards "unoriginal" gameplay, just because genres
aren't being created every week doesn't mean there isn't anything original
out there. Just look at movies. What other genre of movies can you make?
And yet decades after their invention we still get cool stuff. Whether you
liked it or not, you have to admit Blair Witch was a nice experiment.
I'm probably stretching your letter to much more than what you meant, but
why the hell not, ya know? Oh, and I only their famous songs, but I can
tell REM rocks. And this is from a man whose favorite band is Metallica.
-Clyde Hudman
|
Hey there Clyde, long time no talk! Anyway, I'd tend to agree with you.
Creativity in plot is good, I
think, but an average story that's well presented is better than something
totally creative yet crappy.
There are so many variables in a story that you can make something
original, the combinations will
never be exhausted -- yet certain themes will likely be reused. Again,
it's in the presentation and development
of the story. For it to be effective, it has to somehow have a hook that
draws you in and makes you
care about the outcome. More jaded players will have trouble with this in
all likelihood, and probably
tend to buy fewer games than newer gamers. It's all good, though.
Closing Comments:
Send letters.
-Andrew Kaufmann |
|
|
|