The changing of the guards - July 9th, 1999 - Drew Cosner
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed within this column are those of the participants and the moderator, and do not neccessarily reflect those of the GIA. There is coarse language and potentially offensive material afoot. I am the man found dead at the bottom of Shamu's tank. Don't say I didn't warn you.
Well, this is it. Allan's had to take his leave so that he can readjust to college life and living independently. He should be back to host weekends once things settle down, so you're not forever without his own special brand of wit.
Now begins my reign... or something. I've had my practice, and I think I'm good and ready to take whatever the life of the daily letters columnist can throw at me. So bring it on. Is that the best you can do?
To be serious for just a moment, something I generally try to avoid doing, I'm going to do my best to not only keep the column as fresh and humorous as it was before, but hopefully make it even a little better. I look forward to hearing from you readers, and I think we're going to get along just fine. Sound good? Good, then let's get this crap in gear.
Who was that man? I'd like to shake his hand. |
OK, so I was reading "Mister Warthog and his explorations into the
Free Parking square in Monopoly," and an incredibly silly question
popped into my head. Do you know whether it was Uematsu or Mitsuda who
wrote the Magus battle music in Chrono Trigger?
Gotta go, I've got a headache the size of a warthog from Albany.
- A braindead incredibly pungent piece of dog crap and a big bag of
South Central straight out of Compton
|
Yes, I do know as a matter of fact. It was Mister Mitsuda who wrote that fine little ditty. Reading this letter reminds me that I have to update the nickname creator. I'll work on that sometime this upcoming week. Then you can waste more of your time repeatedly clicking a button to generate barely-coherent nicknames too long to be spouted out in a single breath. I know I'm looking forward to it.
Voice out your opinions |
Now, granted voice could not be used for all things. Exceptionally long
games would have a hard time cramming it all in. But I think voices
ought to be used more extensively in the new systems.
I've heard a number of arguments against voice:
1.) That you can't rename your characters.
Well, yeah that would be one thing we could get along
without, though. RPG fans might be upset by this but no one I know
complains "man I wish that his name wasn't Leon," or "Crap, 'solid
snake?' what kind of a name is that?" Yeah, you can't get that same
sense of empathy with the characters, but over all the game has more of
a 'novel' or 'movie' feel to it if the characters are pre-named. That's
pretty much the feel I want from a game, but hey, all interests are
different.
2.) Voice acting is dangerous. What if we have horrible voice actors?
Giving the fact that square has given us mediocre (Ok fine--
BAD) translations, they would likely not have top notch voices. This
concerns me a little. Resident Evil 1 I thought was pretty bad, but RE2
was decent. There WAS a noticeably difference. Metal Gear I thought
did an excellent job, there were no horrible voices there.
3.) If square did a good job with voices, music would suffer.
I think MGS is a good example how voices and music can both
coexist happily. Someone said Grahf's theme in Xenogears would be
drowned out by voice. I think it would add to the feel if a raspy-voice
guy said those lines to the backdrop of that music. I'm thinking maybe
the ninja in MGS would do a good Grahf-voice. The other thing is that
RE2 (which some felt the voice was crappy, but I think it was at least
decent) had a great atmosphere music score that, coupled with the
voices, created a very good feel to the game.
4.) I want my bad translations!
People who think this are really not worth anything. They
should not be allowed to breathe the same air we do, nor consume the
precious space on this planet earth. Why would anyone actually like
reading crap?
5.) What about the deaf?
This more recent argument caught me off guard. It would be
a shame to lose the deaf audience, so I would favor a text and voice
thing, similar to MGS. You know how the screen sort of went to
widescreen format to display the words below the scenes? That sort of
thing.
All right that sums up my feelings on this issue pretty much. I may
seem like I point at MGS too much for what the average voice game is
like, but I really do think it is the best example of what is possible
in a game.
Wow, my hands hurt from writing too much...
-Alexander3025
|
My basic sentiment is that if the voice acting is good, it only adds to the game, just as good music adds to a game. Bad voice acting certainly doesn't help, but if the rest of the game makes up for it, it can usually be overlooked. An excellent example would be Resident Evil, the benchmark for crappy voice acting.
However, I'm not sure I could handle an entire 40 hour RPG if the voice acting totally blew. I'm afraid to come near Star Ocean 2, I might have to eject it from my Playstation and throw it into oncoming traffic after five hours of that horrid post-battle commentary. However, if the voice acting was done well, it could certainly make the experience more immersive and cinematic in presentation. You may or may not agree with me on this one, but personally I thought FFVII's ending would have been all that much better with a little verbalization. The whole movie-like presentation with nothing but background music thing just didn't do it for me.
In it for the music |
Hey Drew -
In today's column, you say that you doubt anyone buys a game specifically
for the composer of the music. Well, I have to disagree. I can honestly
say that Nobuo Uematsu's score was the *only* reason I ever picked up
Final
Fantasy VII. After I had already decided that I hated the game's
polygonal
graphics, that FF7 had completely strayed from the medieval setting I
liked,
and that the game was basically a complete disgrace to its name and a
crime
against mankind, I heard Uematsu's score and fell completely in love with
it. I bought the $45 soundtrack from Game Music Online, and later the
game
itself. And, it was largely because of Uematsu's moving compositions that
FF VII is not only my favorite game soundtrack ever, but also my favorite
Final Fantasy game. So, it's basically thanks to Nobuo Uematsu that I
picked up a game I had already dismissed and enjoying it tremendously.
Anyone who doesn't appreciate some of the great music we get in RPGs is
definitely missing out.
- Kaxon
|
Hey, to each his own I guess. If you really think the game sucks that much, I can't imagine sticking it out for the duration just because you like the music, especially when you already own the soundtrack, but that's just me. Further proving that everybody has their opinion, a lot of people felt the 16-bit sounding musical scores were one of FFVII's low points.
Oh, and there's no way in Hell I'm going to touch your comments regarding FFVII. That's one argument I'd like to see chained to a Kia and tossed to the bottom of the ocean.
Bet my multiparter's longer than yours |
Drew,
Well, many a question and answer again.
1. N64 has left me dissapointed. No RPGs whatsoever, and it just plain sucks. The problem is, my brother stole my first edition one, and i had to get a new one. one problem, i have to share it with a sibling, who is impervious to videogames and hardly ever plays. Should i dump it and collect cash and get a DC? Or just get the cash?
|
Personally, I think the N64 has enough games to make it worth keeping around. And hey, you made the mistake of asking me for my opinion, so now you're just going to have to hear it. The RPG line up is pretty much nonexistent, but with upcoming games like Zelda Gaiden and Ogre Battle (assuming Nintendo decides to brings it stateside), there's going to be some good stuff coming out in the near future. Me, I'm just praying for Earthbound 64, baby. What other series lets you beat the hell out of little piles of space vomit with baseball bats and frying pans while trying to save the world from your next-door neighbor? Gotta love it.
2. Sega has disappointed me alot. I bought a Saturn recently, about Thanksgiving last year, to collect some RPG goodness. Will DC have that? Or am I stuck with Sonic Adventure (which I have played, it was ok, BTW)?
|
That's a really tough one to call. There's a pretty decent sized lineup of RPGs slated for Sega's upcoming system, but the quality remains to be seen. I'm not saying the games for it will inherintly suck, I'm just saying that it's simply too early to call. Shen Mue should be excellent, and the Phantasy Star team is already working on their own little project currently known as Project Ares, so there should be some quality games to fiddle with.
Sega has a year head-start, we'll just have to wait to see if all the pieces fall into place. I'd hate to see a company that's been around cranking out consoles for so long totally bite the dust after such a valiant effort, but that's the way the industry is.
3. roric was right: All RPG message boards basically turned into bitch boards. Take a look at the FF Series MB on GIA. Not to name alias' but some people have done just what he said. The SO2 board seems to be only helpful.
|
General rule of life: People love to bitch. Seriously. About anything. The world could suddenly be transformed into a beautiful paradise, and somebody would bitch that the rdiant sunshine was making their skin itch. Since etiquette prevents people from allowing the animal within to take over and go around growling and snapping at one another's necks, we allow it to manifests itself as an insatiable urge to bitch.
4. Square will probably crap up CC. With what they ahve been doing now, I wouldnt be surprised. The legions will not be pleased.
|
That's the spirit! After years of moaning and groaning that our beloved Chrono Trigger would never get the sequel it so deserved, when news of a sequel is finally revealed everybody's instinct is to cynically cry out, "It's gonna suck, dude!". When you start to play a game scrutinizing it down to the very minutiae, just because you're so sure it's going to suck, how the hell can you expect to enjoy it? Did you start playing the original Chrono Trigger thinking to yourself, "Jeez, after FFVI, everything Square does will be a letdown. I think I'll try and point out every minor detail that can be seen as sucking".
Don't get me wrong, square ain't exactly lilly white, but if you play a game intent on finding reasons why it sucks, you better believe you're not going to enjoy it.
5. PocketStation, if it ever makes it here, won't be worth it, IMO. I've seen it up to $80 online, and one for $90 in a mall somewhat close to me. Plus the battery is bad, not that long lasting. Plus add non-existant aviability, plus no games. So what's the point?
|
Assuming the Pocketstation makes it to America, it would only be about 30 bucks. And yeah, from what I hear they suck on battery life. To be honest, I doubt it would enjoy the success here that it has in Japan, though. But then, I swear the Japanese will buy any piece of plastic that has a microchip inside, no matter what it does.
6. Random stuff: SO2's bunny is named Barney, BTW.
|
All the more reason it should rot in the darkest corners of Hell.
7. FF8, everyone will buy it, just because, we will have the same gripes like FF7.
|
See my reply to your 4th comment.
And that's it. Again covering basically everything on the forefront. Any questions?
-Nameles
|
Nope. We at The GIA thank you for the submission of your editorial. We will pass it through our panel of reviewers, and we will notified you of your status by mail within 6 to 8 weeks. Thank you for entering.
Settings |
Wirst of all, good luck as full time letters guy, Drew. ;)
Second, I just wanted to take Allan's idea on more original RPG settings
and run with it for a little bit. Personally, I'd like to see an RPG with
settings resembling those of the Antiquity. Greek/Roman classical
architecture? How about a town resembling Jerusalem or Tyre or Rome? Port
cities, people wearing robes, sea trading, the Silk Road...all mushed
together. You know, like the Middle Ages on crack except now it's the
Antiquity on crack. My dream RPG is set in a world like this. =)
I'd go into more detail but it's late. *Yawn*....
-Al 'David
|
Sounds good. Personally, as well as the backdrop for an RPG is well crafted I'm not a stickler for the feel to it. I liked FFVII's futuristic feel, mainly Midgar, I liked Zelda's medieval setting, and I even liked Earthbound's more down to earth locales (and that rank pun was not intended, I assure you). Why limit yourself to enjoying only one or two types of settings? As long as a game's world is detailed and well-designed so as to draw you further into the game, a few castles or automobiles shouldn't be a deciding factor as to whether or not you enjoy it.
Jeez, I'm pretty damn Zen-like and non-offensive today. What's up with that?
It's rude to lick your fingers at the dinnertable |
Drew, should I eat my hands? They look really, really tasty.
|
As the first person to send me an entirely assinine and startlingly odd attempt at humor as Double Agent, I award you Drew's Sexalicious Award. May you print this page and make a little pin out of it to show off to all of your friends and family with pride. Despite the fact that it will be rather small once printed out, everyone you meet will be filled with desire and lust whenever you are in their presence. Use its powers only for good, or else I'll have no choice but to send an armada of heat seeking tornadoes, vicious dogs, breakdancers, and guys humping pogo sticks after you next time you're on your paper delivery route. When everyone realizes that you are incapable of weilding the awesome powers of the Sexalicious Award, they'll paint their houses red and discontinue their pre-paid subscriptions, despite being only midway through them. I know that neither of us really wants that.
Edutainment that doesn't totally suck |
Drew,
This is in response to Raymond Wu's question about punctuation and quotation marks. If all of you are like me--confused daily by the vicissitudes of grammar, here are some pointers:
Commas and Periods
ALWAYS put commas and periods INSIDE quotation markes UNLESS you are employing citation information.
FOR EXAMPLE:
1. "This isn't fair," Edward said, "why am I so lame?"
2. John Keats laments his impeding death as he writes, "When I have fears that I may cease to be/Before my pen has gleaned my teaming brain" (1-2).
Colons and semicolons
ALWAYS put semicolons and colons outside OUTSIDE quotation marks.
The following poem is from W.B. Yeats's "He Wishes for the Cloths of Heaven":
Had I the heavens' embroidered cloths,
Inwrought with golden and silver light;
The blue and the dim and the dark cloths,
Of night and the light and the half light;
I would spread the cloths under your feet.
But I, being poor, have only my dreams;
I have spread my dreams under your feet.
Tread softly, because you tread on my dreams.
One of my favorite poems. :)
Some points about proper marking of Question Marks and Exclamation Points
Place ? and ! INSIDE quotation marks UNLESS they are applicable to the material as a whole, ok?!
1. On the cross, it is said that Jesus laments, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?"
2. How many times a day do you hear "you can't teach an old dog new tricks"?
The question mark is placed outside the quotation marks in numero two because the entire sentence is a question; whereas, the question mark in the first sentence is tethered only to the quoted material.
There ya go! I hope it helps!
-Josh Reid
|
Thanks Josh. Not only are my columns a bunch of cynical viewpoints and random thoughts formed into nearly-coherent sentences on my part, they're also learning experiences. Stay tuned next week when I teach you how to hate a videogame before even playing it backwards on a snowboard in only your boxer shorts all while slamming a Dew.
3D just to spite you |
Hey guys,
As much as I liked Chrono Trigger, I cant help but say that
if Chrono Cross doesnt sport graphics in the quality of Saga Frontier 2 and
Legend of Mana (2 very good games) that i wont buy the game. I will know
first hand when I import Legend of Mana. I try not being biased, but no
matter how I look at it i always see polygon graphics as the most ugliest
thing in the world. Hence, I can't stand most games that are totally based
around polygon graphics. Games like Star Ocean 2 just tickle my fancy. Being
an anime man, I am really hoping that Chrono Cross will sport some well done
watercolor sprite graphics.
-The Potato Man
|
Well, guess what? It's in 3D! Although he finally agreed to the creation of a Chrono Trigger sequel, Allan excerted his ungodly control over Square and insisted the game be entirely 3D to piss of 2D purists and people incapable of accepting change the world over. Allan always gets the last laugh. Before taking his leave of absence from DA, he had sex with all of your girlfriends just to show you.
I only hope I can fill such shoes.
Closing Comments
So get this. In order to prove to us Americans that they really aren't a bunch of corporate tight asses with no grounds in reality nor their Western consumer base, Square has decided to host their own little ESPN2 "extreme" event. That's a swell idea! Everybody knows the best way to win over Americans is to sponsor an event featuring such "extreme" sports as skateboarding, bicycling and rollerblading, all of which have been played out by every other corporate empire looking to prove how hip they are to the extent that they're about as out-there as needle point.
Square reminds me of the nerdy kid in school who always looked down his nose at everyone until he realized he was pissing people off and hosted a tea party to win back favor, only to look all the more the condesending ass. What, you mean there wasn't one of those kids at every elementary school?
And thus ends today's column. I have to save some of these outstated opinions for later columns, with an entire week to fill I can't spread my cynicism too thin.
-Drew Cosner, your long lost uncle
|
|
|
|